Redesigning after-sales service: Impact on incumbent product distribution channels
With the growth of multi-channel retailing, many firms that have traditionally relied upon third-party service providers to offer after-sales service (AS) have introduced direct AS channel. While there exist a few studies that examine the effects of adding a direct sales channel on the sales revenue...(Read Full Abstract)
With the growth of multi-channel retailing, many firms that have traditionally relied upon third-party service providers to offer after-sales service (AS) have introduced direct AS channel. While there exist a few studies that examine the effects of adding a direct sales channel on the sales revenue of incumbent channels, there are no studies investigating the effects of adding direct AS channel. This study tries to fill this research gap by exploring cross-channel effects of including AS through the firm's direct brand stores on performance (i.e., revenue, assortment width, and extent of upselling) in both direct and indirect channels. A matched difference-in-difference quasi-experimental design was used to compare the sales outcomes of test and control groups using a five-year longitudinal dataset from a large dual-channel consumer durables firm. Results reveal that providing AS through the firm's direct channel has a positive significant effect on the revenue and upselling in the indirect channel, but no significant impact on assortment width in the indirect channel. However, unlike hypothesized, it results in significantly lower revenue, assortment width, and upselling in the direct channel. We interpret these negative effects as arising from customer confusion and perceived retail crowding. Overall, our research highlights that implementation of going direct with AS should be done with utmost care. Our findings would serve as a building block for future studies that are conducted to understand the dynamic cross-channel effects of introducing direct AS, and would be useful for drawing comparisons and contrasts. © 2020 Elsevier Ltd
Uncertainty and affluent teenagers’ luxury buying-decision: the role of avoidance-related indecisiveness
-
Authors: Sanyal S.N., Mazumder R., Singh R., Sharma Y.
Year: 2021 | IIM Calcutta
Source: Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services DOI: 10.1016/j.jretconser.2020.102305
|
|
Global teen population constitutes a sizable market in the luxury brands industry. However, little is known about the mechanism through which teens form an attitude towards luxury brands, particularly in the context of emerging economies. Drawing insights from self-concept theory, self-discrepancy t...(Read Full Abstract)
Global teen population constitutes a sizable market in the luxury brands industry. However, little is known about the mechanism through which teens form an attitude towards luxury brands, particularly in the context of emerging economies. Drawing insights from self-concept theory, self-discrepancy theory, and social consumption motivation, our study proposes a theoretical framework to explain how teenagers' self-related perception influence social consumption motives through avoidance-related indecisiveness, thereby determining teenagers' attitude towards luxury brands. Using a sample of 610 affluent private school students across five major cities of India, we empirically validate our theoretical framework through structural equation modelling. Our study contributes to the existing literature by demonstrating the impact of teenagers’ self-perception on the display of avoidance-related indecisiveness and resisting social consumption motives of luxury brand purchases. © 2020 Elsevier Ltd
A heuristic approach for cluster TSP
-
Authors: Manna A., Maity S., Roy A.
Year: 2020 | IIM Calcutta
Source: Studies in Computational Intelligence DOI: 10.1007/978-3-030-34152-7_4
|
|
This investigation took an attempt to solve the cluster traveling salesman problem (CTSP) by the heuristic approach. In this problem, nodes are clustered with given a set of vertices (nodes). Given the set of vertices is divided into a prespecified number of clusters. The size of each cluster is als...(Read Full Abstract)
This investigation took an attempt to solve the cluster traveling salesman problem (CTSP) by the heuristic approach. In this problem, nodes are clustered with given a set of vertices (nodes). Given the set of vertices is divided into a prespecified number of clusters. The size of each cluster is also pre-specified. The main aim is to find the least cost Hamiltonian tour based on the given vertices. Here vertices of each cluster visited contiguously, and the clusters are visited in a specific order. Standard GA is used to find a Hamiltonian path for each cluster. The performance of the algorithm has been examined against two existing algorithms for some symmetric TSPLIB instances of various sizes. The computational results show the proposed algorithm works well among the studied metaheuristics regarding the best result and computational time. © Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2020.
A Mathematical Model to determine the Reliability Percentage of a Statement using the Bounded Confidence of Opinion Dynamics
-
Authors: Basak J., Nath P., Bhaumik P.
Year: 2020 | IIM Calcutta
Source: Proceedings - International Conference on Smart Electronics and Communication, ICOSEC 2020 DOI: 10.1109/ICOSEC49089.2020.9215409
|
|
Opinion Dynamics procures a prudent tool for modeling opinion management. Existing studies primarily focused on agent-based opinion measures, which was the key issue in the field of Opinion Dynamics. The primary domain of this study is to determine the reliability of a statement with the help of agg...(Read Full Abstract)
Opinion Dynamics procures a prudent tool for modeling opinion management. Existing studies primarily focused on agent-based opinion measures, which was the key issue in the field of Opinion Dynamics. The primary domain of this study is to determine the reliability of a statement with the help of aggregated group opinion values of the associated local agents. This paper proposes a new Mathematical model of Opinion Dynamics which is a slight modification of the Bounded Confidence model to find the Reliability Percentage of a statement. In Opinion Dynamics the Bounded Confidence model is represented as a stochastic model that evolves continuous-valued opinions within a finite group of agents. Based on the opinion values given by the local agents regarding any situation, our mathematical model computes aggregated group opinion which is used to find the Reliability Percentage of a statement that is associated with the same situation. A real data set on the Nepal earthquake is used to illustrate and justify the feasibility of the proposed mathematical model. With this model, the effects of the reliability percentage are explored based on two different Twitter statements.. © 2020 IEEE.
A noble genetic algorithm to solve a solid green traveling purchaser problem with uncertain cost parameters
-
Authors: Roy A., Gao R., Jia L., Maity S., Kar S.
Year: 2020 | IIM Calcutta
Source: American Journal of Mathematical and Management Sciences DOI: 10.1080/01966324.2020.1805060
|
|
The traveling purchaser problem (TPP) is a notable generalization of the traveling salesman problem (TSP) which involves selecting a subset of markets at a minimum traveling cost such that the demand for each product is satisfied. A solid green traveling purchaser problem (SGTPP) is a TPP in which, ...(Read Full Abstract)
The traveling purchaser problem (TPP) is a notable generalization of the traveling salesman problem (TSP) which involves selecting a subset of markets at a minimum traveling cost such that the demand for each product is satisfied. A solid green traveling purchaser problem (SGTPP) is a TPP in which, at each market, some conveyances are available to travel to another market with minimum cost considering the environmental impact caused by carbon emission. In this paper, we formulate an SGTPP with travel cost between each pair of markets and purchase price of the products as uncertain variables. Using uncertainty theory, an expected value model is formulated and then transformed into the corresponding deterministic form. Finally, a noble genetic algorithm (nGA) is designed to solve the proposed model. The algorithm is called noble because it adopts a crossover of the combination of a probabilistic selection of three parents, according to real-life In Vitro Fertilization (IVF) techniques. Computational results reveal that our proposal is favorably compared to previous algorithms in the existing literature. © 2020 Taylor & Francis Group, LLC.
A qualitative study to understand the factors affecting the adoption of glass fiber-reinforced gypsum (GFRG) as a sustainable building technology: insights from Indian construction industry
-
Authors: Garg R., Chhikara R., Singh R., Agrawal G., Talwar V., Mehra V.
Year: 2020 | IIM Calcutta
Source: Construction Innovation DOI: 10.1108/CI-12-2019-0153
|
|
This paper aims to assess the factors favoring the adoption of the challenges faced and support mechanism, which will lead to the proliferation of glass fiber-reinforced gypsum (GFRG) technology in India. Design/methodology/approach: Semi-structured interviews with 35 experts, including construction...(Read Full Abstract)
This paper aims to assess the factors favoring the adoption of the challenges faced and support mechanism, which will lead to the proliferation of glass fiber-reinforced gypsum (GFRG) technology in India. Design/methodology/approach: Semi-structured interviews with 35 experts, including construction developers, architects, contractors, government officials and design consultants, were conducted. This qualitative data was analyzed using thematic analysis and matrix analysis. Findings: GFRG-based buildings produce much less carbon footprints as compared to traditional ones and can be safely recommended as a promising, environmentally sensitive technology of the future. The major drivers in its adoption are its efficient construction capability, energy and soil conservation and significant waste reduction. Some of the challenges in implementation are long planning time, lack of skilled labor, lack of awareness about green building technologies and myopic perception of high cost incurred in green building adoption in people’s minds. Practical implications: This study establishes that the construction industry has the potential to contribute toward creating a sustainable and green planet. It does so by evaluating and then positively positioning GFRG as an environmentally friendly building system. Originality/value: The harmful effects of continuous environmental manipulation by humans leading to its degradation is a critical discussion agenda for most nations of the world. The issue has been taken up seriously by developing countries, and now, developing countries are also becoming sensitised to it. Several policies toward the attainment of this goal have been formulated and are being implemented by government and private bodies. Although some authors have studied the issues and challenges related to the adoption of green buildings, their attempts mostly focused on developed countries. Moreover, research that investigated the evaluation of the GFRG building system as a successful green technology of the future is inadequate. © 2020, Emerald Publishing Limited.
A road less traveled in nostalgia marketing: impact of spiritual well-being on effects of nostalgic advertisements
-
Authors: Singh R., Sharma Y., Kumar J.
Year: 2020 | IIM Calcutta
Source: Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice DOI: 10.1080/10696679.2020.1836975
|
|
Spiritual well-being plays an integral role in the reconstruction of past events. In this direction, the current study investigates how differences in individuals’ spiritual well-being elicit different cognitive and emotional responses to nostalgic ads. And how such differences in spiritual well-bei...(Read Full Abstract)
Spiritual well-being plays an integral role in the reconstruction of past events. In this direction, the current study investigates how differences in individuals’ spiritual well-being elicit different cognitive and emotional responses to nostalgic ads. And how such differences in spiritual well-being lead to the different purchase intention of nostalgic products. We displayed a series of old Indian ads to respondents and found spiritual well-being influenced ad-evoked nostalgia and purchase intention of nostalgic products positively. Our study contributes to a road less traveled in nostalgia marketing and necessitates marketers to consider audiences’ spiritual well-being before applying nostalgic appeal. © 2020 Taylor & Francis Group, LLC.
Advertisement revenue management: Determining the optimal mix of skippable and non-skippable ads for online video sharing platforms
-
Authors: Chakraborty S., Basu S., Ray S., Sharma M.
Year: 2020 | IIM Calcutta
Source: European Journal of Operational Research DOI: 10.1016/j.ejor.2020.10.012
|
|
Skippable video advertisements (ads), which allow uninterested users to skip the ad after a few seconds, have witnessed rapid growth in the past few years. While their advantages for viewers and advertisers are obvious, they pose an ad revenue optimization problem for their publishers, i.e., the Vid...(Read Full Abstract)
Skippable video advertisements (ads), which allow uninterested users to skip the ad after a few seconds, have witnessed rapid growth in the past few years. While their advantages for viewers and advertisers are obvious, they pose an ad revenue optimization problem for their publishers, i.e., the Video Sharing Platforms (VSPs). The VSPs need to critically balance the higher but uncertain revenue from skippable ads with the lower but guaranteed revenue from non-skippable ads. This problem is particularly challenging because non-skippable ads cause higher disutility to viewers. Moreover, due to network effect, this disutility has a long term impact on the VSPs’ revenue. In this paper we study the revenue management problem faced by a VSP in determining the optimal mix of skippable and non-skippable ads. We model VSP as a two sided platform, identify conditions under which an advertiser would prefer skippable ads over non-skippable ones, and derive the optimality conditions for VSP's optimal ad mix. Our model reveals the existence of an upper bound on number of non-skippable ads, such that continued violation of this upper bound leads to a cascading effect, resulting in a reduction of both skippable and non-skippable ads over time. Our analysis helps a VSP in determining the incentive it should provide to the advertisers to switch to its preferred ad type. Our study reveals that non-skippable ads are essential for VSPs with niche or low content, and the proportion of skippable ads increases as the content increases or becomes more general. © 2020 Elsevier B.V.
An experimental investigation of newsvendor decisions under ambiguity
-
Authors: Shinde A., Mehta P., Amit R.K.
Year: 2020 | IIM Calcutta
Source: International Journal of Production Research DOI: 10.1080/00207543.2020.1797206
|
|
The literature on decision biases in the newsvendor model assumes classical version of the problem where the distribution of random demand is known. This context is decision-making under risk. In many real-life settings, firms are not able to elicit complete and exact information about the demand di...(Read Full Abstract)
The literature on decision biases in the newsvendor model assumes classical version of the problem where the distribution of random demand is known. This context is decision-making under risk. In many real-life settings, firms are not able to elicit complete and exact information about the demand distribution. This results in decision-making under ambiguity. We examine the newsvendor ordering preferences under ambiguity. Our study is the first attempt in behavioural operations management research to examine the biases in newsvendor decisions under ambiguity. We design experiments to understand the ordering preferences under ambiguity and risk. The experimental results show that subjects deviate from the normative benchmarks. We observe ‘pull-to-center’ bias in newsvendor decisions under ambiguity. We also observe that subjects exhibit ‘asymmetry in ordering’. Both these biases have significant implications for both theory and practice. Our research is a building block for research in a variety of normative models in operations management literature where ambiguity in demand is a highly relevant context for decision-making. © 2020 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group.
Application of Image Data Analytics for Immediate Disaster Response
-
Authors: Chaudhuri N., Bose I.
Year: 2020 | IIM Calcutta
Source: ACM International Conference Proceeding Series DOI: 10.1145/3369740.3372729
|
|
This study identifies a novel source of data, i.e. images from smart urban infrastructures, that would be helpful in effective disaster management decision-making. For this purpose, we collected images from disaster-hit environments of Central Mexico (2017 earthquake). Also, this study utilizes deep...(Read Full Abstract)
This study identifies a novel source of data, i.e. images from smart urban infrastructures, that would be helpful in effective disaster management decision-making. For this purpose, we collected images from disaster-hit environments of Central Mexico (2017 earthquake). Also, this study utilizes deep learning convolutional neural network to analyze this novel dataset and evaluates the model effectiveness and technical viability during crisis scenarios. TensorFlow was utilized for the image classification task. The findings have important significance for effective disaster response. © 2020 ACM.
Attitudinal barriers in education: Experiences of women with disabilities in Odisha
-
Authors: Satapathy S.
Year: 2020 | IIM Calcutta
Source: Economic and Political Weekly
|
|
Women with disabilities are subjected to double discrimination in Indian society. Despite growing concern for the disabled community in society at large, their education remains only aspirational. The attitudes that women with disabilities encounter in their educational endeavours are explored. A th...(Read Full Abstract)
Women with disabilities are subjected to double discrimination in Indian society. Despite growing concern for the disabled community in society at large, their education remains only aspirational. The attitudes that women with disabilities encounter in their educational endeavours are explored. A thematic analysis of 27 narratives of women with disabilities from Odisha identifies and distinguishes the familial and communal attitudes they face. Policy must aim at ensuring not just physical integration, but also the social acceptance and inclusion of women with disabilities. © 2020 Economic and Political Weekly. All rights reserved.
Being (more) Human in a Digitized World
-
Authors: Seetharaman P., Mathew S.K., Sein M.K., Tallamraju R.B.
Year: 2020 | IIM Calcutta
Source: Information Systems Frontiers DOI: 10.1007/s10796-020-10020-9
|
|
Women with disabilities are subjected to double discrimination in Indian society. Despite growing concern for the disabled community in society at large, their education remains only aspirational. The attitudes that women with disabilities encounter in their educational endeavours are explored. A th...(Read Full Abstract)
Business models shifts: Impact of Covid-19
No amount of crystal ball gazing may help us fathom the full impact of the Covid-19 (C-19) crisis on business organizations in a distinct manner. Given the lack of precedence, any such analyses seem to demand routine revisions as we progress further up the “number of infected” curve. Most countries ...(Read Full Abstract)
No amount of crystal ball gazing may help us fathom the full impact of the Covid-19 (C-19) crisis on business organizations in a distinct manner. Given the lack of precedence, any such analyses seem to demand routine revisions as we progress further up the “number of infected” curve. Most countries of the world have imposed restrictions on social congregations or even people working in close proximity to each other. Industries that produce and deliver information products and services therefore, have continued to function while those that manufacture physical products especially labor-intensive firms were forced to minimize operations or temporarily shut down. However, in most countries, physical products which were essential in nature were reluctantly permitted to be manufactured given the need for them in people's everyday life. In this viewpoint, I draw upon three dimensions – information intensity of product/service, information intensity of process/value chain; along with a third dimension – essential nature of the product/service to help understand the immediate implications of C-19. I also present some anecdotal evidences of attempts to alter business models in these circumstances in order to address the challenges that certain product characteristics impose but at the same capitalize on the business opportunities presented by the essentiality of the products. © 2020 Elsevier Ltd
Buy online and pick up in-store’: Implications for the store inventory
-
Authors: Saha K., Bhattacharya S.
Year: 2020 | IIM Calcutta
Source: European Journal of Operational Research DOI: 10.1016/j.ejor.2020.10.006
|
|
‘Buy online and pick up in-store’ (BOPS), wherein a customer buys the product online and picks it up from the physical store at her convenience, is fast gaining popularity. However, BOPS service complicates the store's inventory policy as BOPS orders, while waiting to be picked up, block inventory a...(Read Full Abstract)
‘Buy online and pick up in-store’ (BOPS), wherein a customer buys the product online and picks it up from the physical store at her convenience, is fast gaining popularity. However, BOPS service complicates the store's inventory policy as BOPS orders, while waiting to be picked up, block inventory and thus delay replenishment requests. The store now has to maintain a base-stock level that is optimal considering both walk-in and BOPS orders. We discuss an inventory control policy that suits this situation. The problem is accentuated when the online channel and the physical store are under different ownerships, since the revenue from BOPS orders will now get shared between the two. In such a scenario, the store may opt for an inventory policy that favours walk-in orders over BOPS requests, as every BOPS order fetches less revenue than every walk-in customer. The extent of restriction on BOPS orders will depend on the revenue-sharing policy and also on the relative frequencies of walk-in and BOPS demands. We discuss two inventory policies that can help the store prioritize walk-in demands over BOPS demands. We compare the performances of the policies proposed, and show that each policy has its claim to supremacy over others in different operating environments, characterized by the input parameters. © 2020 Elsevier B.V.
Can touch interaction predict product-related emotion? a study on mobile augmented reality
-
Authors: Tarafdar P., Leung A.C.M., Yue W.T., Bose I.
Year: 2020 | IIM Calcutta
Source: 26th Americas Conference on Information Systems, AMCIS 2020
|
|
The advancement in immersive technologies provides online retailers the opportunity to integrate augmented reality (AR) experience for their customers. Using AR, the online product presentation is transformed from the pictorial representation to virtual interaction with the products. The virtual pro...(Read Full Abstract)
The advancement in immersive technologies provides online retailers the opportunity to integrate augmented reality (AR) experience for their customers. Using AR, the online product presentation is transformed from the pictorial representation to virtual interaction with the products. The virtual product interaction facilitates online retailers to detect product-related emotion through affective computing. For mobile AR, customers use touch gestures for virtual interaction. Using the theories related to immersive media and affective computing, we hypothesize that the touch movements and touch pressure in AR-based mobile applications are related to positive emotion during product interaction. Moreover, we describe a methodology to establish our hypotheses and to show that these variables can predict the produ ct-related emotion. We expect our research findings to have both theoretical and practical implications. It will explain why touch behavior can predict product-related emotion, and it will also demonstrate online retailers how to implement emotion analytics in AR shopping applications. © 2020 26th Americas Conference on Information Systems, AMCIS 2020. All rights reserved.
China-bashing and Post-COVID-19 narrative: a reality check
-
Authors: Abraham B.P., Nag B., Ray P.
Year: 2020 | IIM Calcutta
Source: Economic and Political Weekly
|
|
The disruption of supply chains caused by COVID-19 has led to predictions that international firms will relocate production away from China, benefiting other emerging economies, including India. However, China's integration with the global economy in terms of international finance, investment, const...(Read Full Abstract)
The disruption of supply chains caused by COVID-19 has led to predictions that international firms will relocate production away from China, benefiting other emerging economies, including India. However, China's integration with the global economy in terms of international finance, investment, construction and as a low-cost location for global production is now so deep that such changes will neither be quick nor painless. In fact, China's innovations might allow it to even reinforce its position in the global economy. © 2020 Economic and Political Weekly. All rights reserved.
Construction of optimal fractional Order-of-Addition designs via block designs
-
Authors: Chen J., Mukerjee R., Lin D.K.J.
Year: 2020 | IIM Calcutta
Source: Statistics and Probability Letters DOI: 10.1016/j.spl.2020.108728
|
|
Order of addition (OofA) experiments have found wide applications. Each order (run) of an OofA experiment is a permutation of m(≥2) components. It is typically infeasible to compare all the m! possible runs, especially when m is large. This calls for experimentation with a subset or fraction of th...(Read Full Abstract)
Order of addition (OofA) experiments have found wide applications. Each order (run) of an OofA experiment is a permutation of m(≥2) components. It is typically infeasible to compare all the m! possible runs, especially when m is large. This calls for experimentation with a subset or fraction of these m! runs. However, only a few systematic results are available on the construction of such fractions ensuring optimality. We employ block designs to propose a systematic combinatorial construction method for optimal fractional OofA designs, and extend the method to construct highly efficient OofA designs, both in much smaller run sizes than the currently available optimal fractions. © 2020 Elsevier B.V.
Consuming beyond means: debt trap of conspicuous consumption in an emerging economy
With high prevalence of conspicuous consumption in low-income emerging economies like India, we argue that households in these economies resort to debts to finance their conspicuous consumption. Using nationally representative household panel data from Indian Human Development Surveys, we provide ev...(Read Full Abstract)
With high prevalence of conspicuous consumption in low-income emerging economies like India, we argue that households in these economies resort to debts to finance their conspicuous consumption. Using nationally representative household panel data from Indian Human Development Surveys, we provide evidence that an increase in conspicuous consumption results in higher household debt and more number of loans, using multiple empirical strategies. We further illustrate that this effect on household debt i) is higher for rural households, and ii) reduces with higher education. We contribute to the literature on conspicuous consumption and its unfavorable consequences in emerging economies. © 2020 Taylor & Francis Group, LLC.
Cultivating online virtual community of purpose to mitigate knowledge asymmetry and market separation of rural artisans in India
-
Authors: Bhattacharyya S., Basak J., Bhaumik P., Bandyopadhyay S.
Year: 2020 | IIM Calcutta
Source: Communications in Computer and Information Science DOI: 10.1007/978-3-030-52014-4_14
|
|
One of the key deficiencies in many marginalized rural communities is lack of linkage to local and larger metropolitan area opportunity structure, financial, technical, social and political resources. The primary reason behind this is the knowledge asymmetry between rural communities and the urban m...(Read Full Abstract)
One of the key deficiencies in many marginalized rural communities is lack of linkage to local and larger metropolitan area opportunity structure, financial, technical, social and political resources. The primary reason behind this is the knowledge asymmetry between rural communities and the urban marketplace and associated agencies, which often disallows rural artisans to sustain profitable entrepreneurial ventures. Knowledge asymmetry occurs when one party (the artisans) in an economic transaction possesses lesser market knowledge (or, lesser understanding about the market context in which a business operates) than the other party (urban marketplace and associated agencies). The resultant market separation derivative of knowledge asymmetry necessitates dependence on middlemen and resultant lack of autonomy for the rural artisans, which often impedes a rural community in achieving workable levels of self-sufficiency. This paper proposes building an online virtual community of purpose to mitigate knowledge asymmetry and market separation of Indian rural artisans. The community of purpose is defined as a community of people, who are going through the same process or are trying to achieve a similar objective. The paper concludes by providing an architectural framework of a Community Information System (CIS), through which we have attempted in building a virtual community of purpose for rural Indian artisans by connecting them digitally with other relevant actors in the craft production system. © Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2020.
Data envelopment analysis in hierarchical category structure with fuzzy boundaries
Data envelopment analysis (DEA) is used for the performance evaluation of a set of decision making units (DMUs). Such performance scores are necessary for taking managerial decisions like allocation of resources, improvement plans for the poor performers, and maintaining high efficiency of the leade...(Read Full Abstract)
Data envelopment analysis (DEA) is used for the performance evaluation of a set of decision making units (DMUs). Such performance scores are necessary for taking managerial decisions like allocation of resources, improvement plans for the poor performers, and maintaining high efficiency of the leaders. In classical DEA, it is assumed that the DMUs are operating in a similar environment. But in practice, this assumption is normally broken as DMUs operate in a varied environment due to several uncontrollable factors like socio-economic differences, competitiveness in the region and location. In order to address this issue, categorical DEA was proposed for the construction of peer groups by creating crisp categories based on the level of competitiveness. However, such categorizations suffer from indeterminate factors, for example, human judgment and biases, linguistic ambiguity and vagueness. In this paper, we propose a more realistic DEA approach which is capable of handling categories defined in natural languages or with vague boundaries and generates efficiency as triangular fuzzy number. The analysis indicates that if a higher degree of fuzziness is allowed while defining the boundaries of the reference set, it results in (1) a compromise with the accuracy, signified by the spread of the fuzzy efficiency, (2) degradation of the quality, signified by the centre of the fuzzy efficiency, of the decision. Finally, the applicability of this approach has been demonstrated using public library data for different regions in Tokyo city. The sensitivity of the optimal decisions to the changes in fuzzy parameters has also been investigated. © 2020, Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature.